The Best Restaurants in the Florida Keys: Top Picks by Region
From oceanfront seafood to laid-back local favorites, Florida Keys restaurants are as much a part of the experience as the water itself.
Each island offers something slightly different. Key Largo feels relaxed and local. Marathon is balanced and central. Key West brings energy and variety.
Whether you’re staying in Key Largo, Marathon, or Key West, this guide highlights some of the best places to eat across the Florida Keys.
Please note that opening hours may vary seasonally, so we recommend confirming directly with each restaurant.
Best Restaurants in Key Largo, Florida
As the gateway to the Keys, Key Largo offers a relaxed mix of waterfront dining and long-standing local favorites, perfect for easing into the rhythm of the islands.
Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen
99336 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo | $$
A long-standing local favorite known for hearty breakfasts, fresh seafood, and classic Key lime pie.
The Fish House
102401 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo | $$
Fresh seafood served simply, with daily catches and local specialties.
Snook’s Bayside Restaurant
99470 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo | $$–$$$
Open-air dining with bay views and live music, especially popular at sunset.
Restaurants in Marathon, Florida Keys
At the heart of the Keys, Marathon blends casual waterfront spots with more refined options, making it one of the most balanced places to dine.
Keys Fisheries
3502 Gulfview Ave, Marathon | $$
Casual waterfront dining known for stone crab (in season) and their famous lobster Reubens.
Butterfly Café
2600 Overseas Hwy, Marathon | $$–$$$
A refined dining spot known for fresh seafood, classic dishes, and a quieter, elegant setting just steps from the water.
Florida Keys Steak and Lobster House
3660 Overseas Hwy, Marathon | $$$
A classic steakhouse setting with a focus on seafood and traditional dishes.
Oceanfront Dining at Isla Bella Beach Resort
Dining at Isla Bella is designed to feel as considered as the setting itself. A collection of restaurants set along a mile of waterfront, where each experience shifts with the time of day, from relaxed lunches to sunset cocktails and refined evening dining.
At explore dining at Isla Bella Beach Resort, each restaurant offers something distinct, all set along a mile of waterfront.
Mahina
View Mahina
1 Knights Key Blvd, Marathon | $$$
A refined oceanfront dining experience featuring fresh Florida Keys seafood with globally inspired flavors.. Expect Hawaiian-inspired flavors, from elevated classics to thoughtfully crafted dishes, all served with sweeping ocean views. Mahina offers a polished yet welcoming setting, ideal for a relaxed yet refined evening by the water. Recognised with OpenTable Diners’ Choice honors, it’s a standout for special occasions. Reservations are recommended for dinner.
Sushi Cabana
View Sushi Cabana
1 Knights Key Blvd, Marathon | $$–$$$
An open-air sushi experience set beside the Yellowfin pool, where ocean views meet a relaxed, al fresco atmosphere. It’s an easy choice for a casual evening with a refined edge, set within an open-air oceanfront setting. Enjoy fresh sushi and sashimi, from Hamachi to King Crab, alongside vibrant rolls and light Japanese dishes beneath palm trees and soft evening lighting.
The Beach Bar
View The Beach Bar
1 Knights Key Blvd, Marathon | $$
Casual bites and cocktails just steps from the water. A relaxed, social setting with front-row ocean views, perfect for long afternoons or sunset drinks. Settle in for a long afternoon or stay as the sky shifts to soft pinks and golds.
Burger Palace
View Burger Palace
1 Knights Key Blvd, Marathon | $–$$
Relaxed, poolside dining made for easy afternoons. A convenient, casual spot for an easy lunch or a break between time by the water. Expect elevated comfort food and a menu that works for both adults and kids.
The Marketplace
View The Marketplace
1 Knights Key Blvd, Marathon | $–$$
When you want something easy and delicious, the Marketplace Café offers both dine-in and grab-and-go options. Ideal for coffee, breakfast, or a quick stop before heading out to explore the Keys. Mornings begin with strong coffee, fresh fruit, and pastries, while all-day selections include wraps, paninis, salads, sandwiches, and house-made desserts.
Best Restaurants in Duck Key, Florida
Smaller and more tucked away, Duck Key offers a quieter dining scene, where waterfront views and relaxed settings take center stage.
Angler and Ale
61 Hawks Cay Blvd, Duck Key | $$–$$$
A laid-back waterfront spot with fresh seafood and marina views.
Salt + Ash
61 Hawks Cay Blvd, Duck Key | $$–$$$
A coastal dining concept by Michelin-starred chef Jeremy Ford, blending bold flavors from land and sea in a refined yet relaxed setting.
Best Restaurants in Key West, Florida
Key West brings energy and variety, with a dining scene that ranges from iconic institutions to creative, locally loved spots.
Blue Heaven
729 Thomas St, Key West | $$–$$$
An iconic open-air restaurant known for Caribbean flavors and a lively atmosphere.
Louie’s Backyard
700 Waddell Ave, Key West | $$$
Oceanfront dining in a historic home with refined cuisine.
Garbo’s Grill
409 Caroline St, Key West | $–$$
A local favorite for bold, fresh flavors in a casual setting.
Latitudes
245 Front St (ferry access), Key West | $$$$
A sought-after dining experience, accessible by ferry only, on Sunset Key, known for its setting and atmosphere.
Where to Stay for the Full Experience
The best way to experience Florida Keys restaurants is to stay somewhere that brings it all together.
If you’re planning a foodie adventure through the Florida Keys, find your room at Isla Bella Beach Resort and stay at the center of it all, with easy access to dining across the islands.
Because here, it’s never just about the meal. It’s about the setting, the pace, and the time to enjoy it.